Alto
Blog
Insights

Roth crypto IRA vs traditional crypto IRA — Which is better?

February 2, 2025
|
Insights
updated on

Cryptocurrencies as a part of retirement plans are a young but rapidly growing trend globally. Investors are viewing cryptocurrencies as a potential growth engine of their retirement portfolios, and a key facilitator of this synergy is crypto IRAs (Individual Retirement Accounts).

When it comes to crypto IRAs, two primary options stand out: 

  1. Traditional crypto IRA
  2. Roth crypto IRA

While both options offer tax advantages and allow you to invest in digital assets, they differ significantly in how and when you receive their tax benefits.

The choice between these two account types can have a substantial impact on your retirement savings, affecting everything from your current tax situation to your future withdrawal strategy. Understanding these differences is crucial for making an informed decision that aligns with your long-term financial goals. 

This blog will cover the differences between a Roth crypto IRA and a traditional crypto IRA, helping you decide which option is better for your retirement plans.

What is a traditional crypto IRA?

Traditional crypto IRAs combine cryptocurrency investing with traditional IRA tax benefits. Your contributions reduce your current taxable income through tax deductions, and your crypto investments grow tax-deferred until retirement. When you withdraw funds in retirement, they're taxed as ordinary income (however, tax penalties may apply if you withdraw those funds prior to turning 59.5 years old).

Key benefits of a traditional crypto IRA

1. Immediate tax benefits: Contributions may lower your current taxable income

2. No restrictions on contributions: No income restrictions on who can contribute

3. Tax-deferred growth: Investments compound without annual tax implications

4. Employer plan rollovers: Easy to rollover old 401(k)s and other retirement accounts

What is a Roth crypto IRA?

Roth crypto IRAs take a "pay taxes now, save later" approach. While contributions are made with after-tax dollars (no immediate tax break), your cryptocurrency investments grow completely tax-free. When you make qualified withdrawals in retirement, you pay zero taxes on all your gains.

Plus, there are no required minimum distributions (RMDs), giving you more control over your money.

Key Benefits of a Roth crypto IRA

  1. Tax-free growth: All qualified withdrawals, including investment gains, are tax-free.
  2. Flexible withdrawals: You can withdraw contributions (not gains) penalty-free before retirement.
  3. No RMDs: Keep your money invested as long as you want.
  4. Estate planning: Ideal for leaving tax-free assets to beneficiaries.

Key differences between traditional and Roth crypto IRAs

Here is a table to easily understand the differences between traditional crypto IRAs and Roth crypto IRAs.

When to choose a traditional crypto IRA?

Consider a traditional crypto IRA if:

  • You want to lower your taxable income immediately.
  • You expect to be in a lower tax bracket during retirement.
  • You prefer to defer taxes on investment growth until withdrawal.

When to choose a Roth crypto IRA?

Consider a Roth crypto IRA if:

  • You can pay taxes upfront without impacting your budget.
  • You anticipate significant growth in your crypto investments.
  • You want to maximize tax-free withdrawals and avoid RMDs.

Getting started with crypto IRAs with Alto

Alto is a leading self-directed IRA platform for alternative investments like cryptocurrencies. Alto offers both types of crypto IRAs discussed in this article: Traditional crypto IRA and Roth crypto IRA.

Reasons to choose Alto for your crypto IRA

Accessibility and affordability

Alto makes crypto retirement investing accessible with a $10 minimum investment and a transparent 1% trading fee. With no monthly maintenance or setup fees, more of your money goes directly into building your retirement portfolio through cryptocurrency investments.

Broad investment options

The Alto CryptoIRA® provides access to more than 250+ cryptocurrencies through its integration with Coinbase, allowing investors to diversify their retirement portfolios with a wide range of digital assets.

Enterprise-grade security

Alto partners with Coinbase to provide secure storage solutions for your cryptocurrency investments, ensuring institutional-grade security for your assets. 

User-focused platform

Take control of your crypto retirement investing with Alto’s intuitive platform, designed for accessibility and convenience. With 24/7 trading, you can act on market opportunities in real-time, ensuring your portfolio remains dynamic and responsive. Alto's mobile app makes managing your investments even easier, putting your retirement strategy at your fingertips—anytime, anywhere. Plus, our comprehensive educational resources and dedicated support team provide the assistance you need, from account setup to ongoing portfolio management.

Tax-advantaged options

Choose between traditional and Roth crypto IRAs to align with your tax strategy, with flexible funding options including transfers and rollovers. SEP IRAs are also available for self-employed individuals.

Creating a crypto IRA account on Alto

  • Visit Alto and sign-in with your email and password.
  • Verify your email and click "Begin Verification" to input your personal information.
  • Select traditional or Roth Alto CryptoIRA® 
  • Provide your phone number, review your details, and e-sign your name in the designated field.
  • Click “Create my Alto CryptoIRA® ” to complete the process and start funding your account.

Fund your account

You can fund your Alto CryptoIRA® in three convenient ways:

  • Cash contributions: Deposit funds directly from your bank account, subject to annual IRS contribution limits.
  • IRA transfers: Directly move funds from an existing IRA without impacting contribution limits.
  • Rollovers: Transfer funds from a 401(k) or other qualified plans into your crypto IRA.

Choose your investments

With Alto’s partnership with Coinbase, you can access over 250+ cryptocurrencies, including Bitcoin, Ethereum, Dogecoin and other emerging digital assets. 

Monitor and manage your crypto IRA

Alto’s intuitive platform makes it easy to manage your investments. Real-time trading and 24/7 access allow you to take advantage of market opportunities while benefiting from institutional-grade security and FDIC-insured cash holdings.

Choosing the right crypto IRA for your future

Whether you choose a traditional or Roth crypto IRA depends largely on your current financial situation and long-term retirement goals. Both options provide valuable tax advantages for cryptocurrency investors, with the main difference being when you receive those tax benefits.

The key is getting started, and Alto makes this process simple and accessible. With a low $10 minimum investment, access to over 250+ cryptocurrencies, and institutional-grade security, you can begin building your crypto retirement portfolio with confidence.

Ready to start your crypto retirement journey?

Invest today
In this article
Subscribe to our newsletter to learn more about Alto.
Share this on

Explore more blogs

Insights

Roth crypto IRA vs traditional crypto IRA — Which is better?

Insights

Cryptocurrency investing for retirement with Alto CryptoIRA®

News

As Seen in the News: How Self-Directed IRAs Can Open New Doors for Retirement Planning